I was certain she did that horrible thing to him before he knew the baby might be his. I remember thinking how awful she was to do this to him when he genuinely thought of her and treated her as a friend.
And that feeling only got worse for me when after the laundry basket incident--he got blasted by his family because they of course thought he fell off the wagon again. He was upset, crying and beating himself up for backsliding and she was just standing there with fake sympathy while he suffered.
Believe it or not, I actually liked Carly when she first arrived because she came in like a tornado. I think the shine got off the diamond shortly after the laundry basket BS.
I did so love the Robin vs Carly arguments. Perfect song choice